Please note: This booklet is only available for download.
The sugya discusses the Talmudic principle of tadir v'she'aino tadir, tadir kodem: when choosing between two mitzvos, the more frequently performed one takes precedence. This rule is derived from a Mishna in
Zevachim, rooted in the order of the korban tamid coming before additional
korbanos. It has many halachic ramifications on a daily basis, but especially
so on the days of Chanuka.
- ·
Which comes first: Maariv
(tadir) or ner Chanuka (pirsum nes)?
- ·
Is there a different
halachic consideration if one lights inside (where there's no pirsum hanes)?
- ·
Should one light Shabbos
candles first (without being mekabel Shabbos) because Shabbos is tadir?
- ·
What about havdala? What is
the prevalent minhag today?
- ·
During Krias Hatorah, when
Rosh Chodesh Teves falls on Shabbos Chanuka, what's the order of the three
different krios?
- · Can the concept of tadir kodem mean that a mitzvah tadirah should be performed at the expense of the less common one, in the event that one cannot perform both? For example, if one only has money for either Neiros Shabbos or Neiros Chanuka, should he choose to light only Shabbos candles (tadir) and not the Chanuka menorah?
- Additional questions addressed that, while not specifically Chanuka-related, are included in the principle of tadir kodem:
- ·
Which goes first: Tallis or
Tefillin?
- ·
What happens if one takes
out the Tefillin first?
- ·
What if the time for Mincha
arrives but one still needs to daven Mussaf?
- ·
Can one recite Kiddush
Levana before Maariv?
- ·
What if one is worried that
the moon may no longer be visible if he waits until after he davens Maariv
(i.e., on a cloudy night)?
- ·
Can one count Sefiras
HaOmer before Maariv?
- ·
Should one perform the
mitzvah of daled minim before Shacharis or before Hallel?
- If one made an early Shabbos and it becomes night during his seuda, should he bentch first, or recite Krias Shema during the seuda?
| Booklet Details | |
| Pages | 95 |
| Published | 5787 |
| Series | Chanuka |
דיני תדיר ושאינו תדיר בקיום המצוות - ובהדלקת נר חנוכה
- Product Code: 336
- Availability: In Stock





